"If anyone really enjoys the kind of wild swings in individual stocks that make no fundamental sense (and, for that matter, swings in the major stock market averages) … then they should just keep proliferating the "derivative" phenomenon of passive vehicles like ETFs and the algorithmic trading (algos) that are creating and profiting from such activity. All of those who say 'I just use index funds' have no idea what they are investing in from a business standpoint. They are essentially allowing black-box models to deploy their investment dollars. [These models] are at the center of the problem with the market mechanism and these investors are actually contributing to the crazy volatility we are seeing, and have been seeing for some time now. It was one thing when so-called 'indexing' was a tiny fraction of the market, but now that almost 35% of invested funds are indexed, it's an entirely different situation. By the assessment of the many "human" traders we work with (yeah, there are still a few left), a whopping two-thirds of trading activity is now being done by algos/passive. Couple that massive increase with the regulations spanning the past twenty years that essentially made it unprofitable for brokerage firms to make markets in OTC stocks (those are the small/mid-sized companies), and you have an illiquid market, subject to the whims of the computers. Of course, as active managers, we will be accused of bias for pointing this problem out: that's fine by us. After 35 years of watching our industry abdicate responsibility for making real investment decisions and come up with "products" that have nothing to do with financing real businesses, frankly, we have no problem saying what we see going on! We've spent our careers watching the biggest of the Wall Street firms get bigger and fewer in number every step of the way. These same firms have been pushing more and more financial 'product' that has nothing to do with raising capital for businesses or providing quality research to real investors. BlackRock now "manages" almost $7 Trillion in assets (or they did, until about three weeks ago). How do you manage $7 Trillion in assets? The answer is: you don't. You create as many vehicles as you can that keep the 'fee train' going: vehicles such as ETFs and index funds, because when you have that much money to manage, you have to own every stock in the world, as the CEO of BlackRock admitted in an interview five years ago that we blogged about (see THIS POST from 2015). |
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar